Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More Menu (Update 2026)

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More offers a fantastic menu filled with comfort food staples. The pizza selection showcases various sizes, from small 9-inch to large 16-inch pizzas. Each option features multiple cuts, ensuring everyone gets their slice of the action. Choose from classic toppings and creative combinations, perfect for any taste.

Soft serve ice cream and rich milkshakes complement the savory offerings, satisfying any sweet tooth. Ice cream choices include tempting flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and twist, alongside hard ice cream varieties and sundaes. With an average price of just $7.60, this spot delivers great value.

For hearty meals, don't miss the jumbo hot Italian sub or the scrumptious chili cheese fries. Whether dining solo or sharing with friends, there's enough to please a crowd.

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More Menu image 1
Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More Menu image 2

Featured Dishes

Bacon Lettuce Tomato & Provolone
Bacon Lettuce Tomato & Provolone
Cheese Pizza
Cheese Pizza
Turkey Club w Bacon
Turkey Club w Bacon
Pepperoni & Provolone
Pepperoni & Provolone
12 Turkey Club
12 Turkey Club
Loaded Fries
Loaded Fries
Pizza & More Menu
Ice Cream Menu
Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More Interior, Food, Ambiance

Karen's Holiday Pizza is a cozy, retro spot nestled on Hubbard Road in Madison. This local gem exudes a friendly, mom-and-pop atmosphere, perfect for casual dining with family or friends. Walls adorned with fun decor mirror the welcoming vibe, inviting guests to sit back and enjoy their meal.

The ambiance is relaxed, with plenty of seating for patrons to enjoy their pizza and ice cream. It’s the kind of place where people come to catch up, with the sounds of laughter and chatter filling the air. Whether you're seated inside or grabbing takeout, the comfort of familiar food awaits.

This hole-in-the-wall location hides a wealth of culinary delights. The combination of delicious food and an inviting atmosphere keeps locals and visitors returning for more.

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More

About Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More Food and Specialties

The star of the show at Karen's is undoubtedly the pizza. Each pie balances a perfectly baked crust, robust sauce, and generous cheese—creating that satisfying melt-in-your-mouth experience. Specialty pizzas lure in the adventurous, while traditionalists can stick to all their favorites.

If pizza isn’t what you crave, the menu extends to subs and calzones, both prepared with fresh ingredients. The jumbo hot Italian sub stands out, filled with savory meats and topped just right. For something different, the gyro packs an authentic flavor punch, transporting you straight to the Mediterranean.

Of course, no visit would be complete without indulging in a creamy milkshake or a delightful sundae, making it a family-friendly haven that creates lasting memories.

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More

The commitment at Karen's Holiday is clear: quality food comes first, fostering a sense of belonging and community spirit. Specializing in homemade-style pizza, fresh subs, and creamy ice cream, the restaurant showcases a dedication to flavor and tradition. Each menu item reflects that the goal is to create a satisfying dining experience for everyone who walks through the door. Their vision is to maintain that local charm while evolving with customer needs, ensuring a space where everyone can feel at home and enjoy delightful meals. Expect consistency in quality and service, reinforcing its reputation as a Madison favorite.