Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More

Discover Karen's Holiday Pizza in Madison, OH, your favorite local spot for delicious pizza, ice cream, subs, and more. Enjoy soft serve, hearty calzones, jumbo hot Italian subs, milkshakes, and weekend specials in a cozy, hole-in-the-wall setting. Call +1 440-428-5217 for takeout or dine-in!

Welcome to Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More

Taste the Difference.

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More
Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More
Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More
Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More

Nestled on Hubbard Rd in Madison, OH, Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More invites you into a cozy, family-friendly atmosphere that defines local dining. This restaurant captures the essence of a classic mom-and-pop shop, where every dish is crafted with care and every guest feels like family. Known for its satisfying pizza and delightful desserts, Karen's stands out as a community favorite. Soft-serve ice cream, delectable milkshakes, and mouthwatering subs fill the menu, ensuring there’s something for everyone.

The welcoming vibe is palpable as soon as you walk through the door, making it the perfect spot for friends and families to unwind. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite or indulging in a sweet treat, Karen's Holiday offers a taste of home that keeps locals coming back.

Directions & Reservations

Plan Your Visit

Address

1362 Hubbard Rd, Madison, OH 44057, United States

Phone

+1 440-428-5217

Social Media

About

The Culinary Story

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More
Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More
Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More
Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More

Karen’s Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More stands out as a beloved dining destination in Madison, OH. This establishment is more than just a meal stop; it’s a community landmark where locals gather to enjoy comforting food in a relaxed environment. They serve various dishes, highlighted by their delicious pizza. From a small, four-cut pizza to a substantial half-sheet item with 16 cuts, every bite promises quality. The 14-inch large pizzas offer a balance of size and flavor that families enjoy.

Beyond pizza, the restaurant excels in its subs, particularly the renowned jumbo hot Italian sub, which is a favorite among regulars for its robust flavors and generous portions. The chili cheese fries, a guilty pleasure for many, add a satisfying crunch to the menu. Even more, guests often indulge in creamy milkshakes and rich sundaes, completing their meals with sweet delights that forge lasting memories. On weekends, especially, the vibe buzzes with families enjoying their meals while kids excitedly sample ice cream treats.

An average visit reveals a culinary journey that delivers satisfaction without a hefty bill, as the average price remains around $7.60. It’s a space where love for food and community connect, making dining here a cherished experience. Great choices exist for any occasion, whether grabbing lunch during the busy workweek or enjoying a leisurely dinner on the weekend.

Work Hours

Availability and Service Times

  • Sunday11 AM-8 PM
  • Monday11 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday11 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday11 AM-9 PM
  • Friday11 AM-9 PM
  • Saturday11 AM-9 PM

Karen's Holiday is more than just a pizza place; it’s a culinary hub in Madison. The menu boasts an impressive range of items, from their signature jumbo hot Italian sub to chili cheese fries that have become a local legend. Famously known for its sheet pizza, perfect for any gathering, this restaurant caters to groups big and small. Ice cream lovers can rejoice with flavors like vanilla, chocolate, and unique twists that refresh on warm days.

Friendly service, a casual setting, and affordable prices make it a fantastic choice for a family outing. Peak hours can be busy, especially on Fridays at 6 PM, so visiting during quieter times is wise to enjoy your meal without the rush. On average, the price for a hearty meal hovers around $7.60, making it an accessible treat for any budget.

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More

Karen's Holiday Pizza, Ice Cream, Subs & More presents a charming yet unpretentious façade that beckons visitors into its warm embrace. The exterior, simple but inviting, allows it to blend beautifully into the Madison neighborhood. The casual outdoor seating option provides a laid-back spot for dine-in customers to enjoy their favorite dishes in the fresh air. This casual setting contributes to the overall community feel, often attracting families, friends, and local enthusiasts who appreciate relaxed dining. The restaurant radiates a welcoming atmosphere, making it easy to settle in and enjoy the experience.

Guestbook & Reviews

Experience Through Their Eyes

Quick and very friendly service. Double checked your order to make sure it's correct. Food is fresh and very well worth the price. Highly recommended

T
Tom R.

Probably some of the best sandwiches in town along with being much more affordable than any fast food restaurant. We always get the pizza from here for our church youth group and is much more inexpensive then the other fast food pizza places. Amazing ice cream and food in a hole in the wall location. They need to clean the place up a bit in my opinion. Maybe change the outside ordering station to newer/cleaner glass and just a bit of an update in general

M
Mason

***updated review at the bottom*** This place has THE BEST SUBS IN ASHTABULA COUNTY! I dare you to find better! We got the turkey club & it was phenomenal! It was so full of meat & veggies, it was amazing! We've tried a lot of subs around town & were about to give up...SO glad we found this place! The staff was super friendly, helpful & accommodating to our schedule too. TEN STARS!!!! Keep up the good work! ***This review was left in 2020. The last year their subs have gone downhill. I wasn't going to say anything but when you pay almost $30 for 2 subs, I feel it would be a disservice not to. The last few subs we've had, had half the meat they used to & the buns are different. These are not the same quality they used to be & definitely not worth the price. Maybe it was the young kids working there or maybe they're cutting costs, I don't know but be aware none the less.***

Z
Zanna

This is an awesome mom and pop restaurant. The ice cream is so delicious. The food is amazing. And the staff go above and beyond.

T
Tiffany P.

Best food in Madison, not even close. What's crazier is that the pricing is even better. My favorite order is a plain cheese, well done pizza with hot BBQ wings and a cookies and cream milkshake. This place has never let me down with anything on menu. Also, amazing subs and if you just want a small bite the hot dogs are great too!

S
Shawn H.

Simply the best Pizza and salad joint in town.. Support your locally owned businesses. Do not order the blue cheese dressing, it's the absolute worst.

S
Shakedown